Skip to Content
Seton Hall University

Inside the Core this Week: Justin Martyr and Augustine  

Saint Augustine 320 pic Inside most Core II classes this week, many students are studying the writings of Justin Martyr and Augustine of Hippo. These two writers represent the development of early Christianity in two eras, showing their dialogue with the surrounding cultures. Since Core II is entitled "Christianity and Culture in Dialogue," these writers can be seen as epitomizing this phrase. They also are quite relevant to us now.

Justin Martyr was born in Neapolis in Samaria, an area which today is called the West Bank. Born into a pagan family, he studied diverse philosophies before becoming a Christian at about thirty, feeling that Christianity fulfilled, as no other philosophy did, the longing for truth that had prompted his searching. However, unlike Tertullian (who famously said, "What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?"), Justin instead sought to reconcile what was best in prior and contemporary pagan philosophies with Christianity. Arguing that former philosophers were essentially "Christians before Christ," so long as they searched and argued for the truth, he was more in line with modern perspectives, like those expressed in Nostra Aetate, that all that is good and true in any religion should be affirmed. Justin even used terminology like Logos, meaning "Word" or perhaps "Wisdom" or "Truth," to describe the nature of Christ – intentionally using a concept familiar to Greek philosophers in order to relate to them meaningfully. However, despite his own open-mindedness, Justin encountered persecution directed against Christians, as a minority group feared and hated as being subversive and a threat to the status quo. He was beheaded in the year 165.

Augustine, born in 354 in Thagaste, Algeria, North Africa, also studied philosophy, but particularly focused on rhetoric. Though his mother was a Christian, and he was trained in that faith, his father was a pagan. With Christianity legalized in 313 by the Emperor Constantine's Edict of Milan, Augustine came of age in a world much like ours – eclectic, hedonistic, and materialistic. Drawn into the seductions around him, he indulged in stealing (the famous pear tree incident), lust, intellectual pride, and worldly ambition. However, the search for truth and the longing for love, ultimately God's love, eventually led him to conversion to Christianity. He says in the Confessions, "Our hearts are restless until they rest in Thee." In his famous City of God, which we read excerpted (Book XIX) in Core II, Augustine distinguishes the difference between the earthly city and the heavenly city, the City of God. The bond of the City is ordered love (meaning love that reflects the order of creation), bringing peace and harmony. Augustine, though rejecting the teaching of rhetoric and pagan literature, uses the skills acquired in his background to make the points in his famous treatise. Love is central to the life of the City of God on earth (as it is in heaven), and ordered love means that one loves appropriately, according to the will of God. Examples would be loving one's child more than one's pet, or loving one's friend more than one's status. There is a hierarchy of values in Augustine's view, and loving rightly is part of loving at all.

Both Augustine and Justin lived at times of transition in the Roman Empire. For Justin, it was a time where Christianity was expanding, an exciting time, but a dangerous one. For Augustine, the dangers were more spiritual, and his search for truth was complicated by desires for other, lesser goods. He came to peace after a spiritual journey that took him from one continent (Africa) to another (Italy in Europe) and back (to Africa) again, and through many philosophical and religious positions. When he finally became a Christian, he had found what he was looking for in the many venues in which he searched.

Today we live in a society that is both complicated and eclectic, but also one that is transitional, and where people who are different can be seen as suspect and even hated (as were the early Christians). In fact, in many parts of the world people are dying for their faith as they did in the time of Justin. But in our culture, like that of Augustine, the dangers may be in some ways worse because they are more subtle. Overall, reading these texts, ancient as they are, can be very important and relevant to life in the world of 2020.

Categories: Education

For more information, please contact:

  • Nancy Enright
  • (973) 275-4847
Back to top